Scholarly Research Paper

Rubric

Assignment Rubric
Assignment Rubric
Criteria Ratings Pts
Introduction

5 pts

Full Marks
Exceptional introduction that grabs interest of reader and states topic. Purpose is exceptionally clear, arguable, well-developed, and a definitive statement.

3 pts

Middle Marks
Proficient introduction that is interesting and states topic. Purpose is clear and arguable statement of position.

2 pts

Low Marks
Basic introduction that states topic but lacks interest. Purpose is somewhat clear and arguable.

0 pts

No Marks
Weak or no introduction of topic. Paper’s purpose is unclear/thesis is weak or missing.
5 pts
Quality of Information/ Evidence

40 pts

Full Marks
Paper is exceptionally researched, extremely detailed, and historically accurate. Information clearly relates to the thesis.

30 pts

Middle Marks
Information relates to the main topic. Paper is well-researched in detail and from a variety of sources.

20 pts

Low Marks
Information relates to the main topic, few details and/or examples are given. Shows a limited variety of sources.

0 pts

No Marks
Information has little or nothing to do with the thesis. Information has weak or no connection to the thesis.
40 pts
Purpose/Analysis

20 pts

Full Marks
Exceptionally critical, relevant and consistent connections made between evidence and purpose. Excellent analysis provided.

10 pts

Middle Marks
Consistent connections made between evidence and purpose. Good analysis provided.

5 pts

Low Marks
Some connections made between evidence and purpose. Some analysis provided.

0 pts

No Marks
Limited or no connections made between evidence and purpose. Lack of analysis provided.
20 pts
Conclusion

5 pts

Full Marks
Excellent summary of topic with concluding ideas that impact reader. Does not introduce new information.

3 pts

Middle Marks
Good summary of topic with clear concluding ideas. Does not introduce new information.

1 pts

Low Marks
Basic summary of topic with some final concluding ideas, but does not introduce new information.

0 pts

No Marks
Lack of summary of topic and introduces new information.
5 pts
Organization/ Development

10 pts

Full Marks
Exceptionally clear, logical, mature, and thorough development of thesis with excellent transitions between and within paragraphs.

7 pts

Middle Marks
Clear and logical order that supports thesis with good transitions between and within paragraphs.

3 pts

Low Marks
Somewhat clear and logical development with basic transitions between and within paragraphs.

0 pts

No Marks
Lacks development of ideas with weak or no transitions between and within paragraphs.
10 pts
Grammar/Usage/ Mechanics

10 pts

Full Marks
Control of grammar, usage, and mechanics. Almost entirely free of spelling, punctuation, and grammatical errors.

7 pts

Middle Marks
May contain few (2-4) spelling, punctuation, and grammar errors.

3 pts

Low Marks
Contains several (5-7) spelling, punctuation, and grammar errors which detract from the paper’s readability.

0 pts

No Marks
Contains frequent (8 or greater) spelling, punctuation, and grammar errors that the paper cannot be understood.
10 pts
APA Formatting

10 pts

Full Marks
Formatting conventions for citations are perfect. Perfect formatting of title and reference pages. Written in appropriate style and voice.

7 pts

Middle Marks
Minor (2-4 errors) errors in APA formatting.

3 pts

Low Marks
Frequent (5 or more) errors in APA formatting.

0 pts

No Marks
Lack of format/numerous errors.
10 pts
Total Points: 100
0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *